question:A bus driver, Peter, is celebrating his 50th brithday at a karaoke. After having several glasses of non-alcoholic drinks,he goes to the washroom. On his way to the washroom in a long hallway, he hears a man’s really loud voice coming out from a room. “Oh please. I didn’t do it. I really didn’t do it. John did it. Please don’t shoot me, Mary.” Then he hears a gunshot. He immediately peeks in through the little window on the door and sees a dead man and a gun on the floor. At a corner of the room, he sees three people standing: a fireman, a nurse and a doctor. The police arrive and question Peter, “Did you see who killed the man?” ”Nope, I didn’t but I’m 100% sure who did it. It was the doctor.” Later the doctor confesses to the murder. So how did Peter know who the killer was?clues:Q: Was the man really dead?A: Yes.Q: Could Peter tell right away what the three people did for living when he first saw them?A: No.Q: Was it apparent who the killer was?A: Yes.Q: Was there anything to do with the gun or how it was placed on the floor after the gunshot?A: No.Q: Were the three people wearing regular casual clothes?A: Yes.Q: Did Peter know any of the people before the murder?A: No. (中文或英文回答都可以,麻煩大家幫幫忙)
- CoyoteLv 52 0 年前最佳解答
1.The three people wearing regular casual clothes, the guy said “Oh please. I didn’t do it. I really didn’t do it. John did it. Please don’t shoot me, Mary.” shows that that guy knows John and Mary to be able to call them by their first name.
2.The doctor and the nurse have more chance to know each other. In the other hand the fireman has less chance to know the others. So the doctor, the nurse and the dead guy could be in the same profession, which rule out the fireman.
3.There are more female nurses than male nurse, so Mary could be the nurse. If it is true, either the dead guy or the dead man is John.
4.According to the voice “I didn’t do it, John did it, Please don’t shoot me Mary”, we can guess Mary believe it and did not shoot him, some body else did it. If that’s true, that rules out the nurse.
5.And the dead man did not kill himself; the only one left with suspicion is the doctor.
- 2 0 年前
一個公共汽車司機，彼得，正在一個卡拉 OK 慶祝他的第 50個 brithday 。 在有非酒精性的飲料一些眼鏡之後，他去盥洗室。 在前往一個長的走廊的盥洗室的途中，他聽到從一個房間出來的男人真大聲的聲音。 ”哦請。 我沒有做它。 我真的沒有做它。 約翰做了它。 請不要射擊我，瑪麗。”然後他聽到一個射擊。 他立刻偷看在經過在門上的小窗戶而且見到在地板上的一個死的男人和一隻槍。 在一個角落
A : 號碼