小天 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 1 0 年前

關係代名詞一問 where/which

We live in a city ______ has lots and lots of people. It\'s not a good idea to drink water unless chemicals have been taken out

(A) that

(B) in which

(C) in that

(D) where

答案是a

可是我一直以為是d

因為a city應該算是地方吧

空格前有名詞a city, 而空格後又有動詞has, 可知空格應置入關係代名詞which, 用以代替其前的名詞並作其所引導的形容詞子句之主詞, 而此關係代名詞which可用that取代, 因此, (A)應為正選。

這是答案的解答 可是沒有提到為什麼不能使用where

拜託解釋一下了

3 個解答

評分
  • 狐狸
    Lv 6
    1 0 年前
    最佳解答

    We live in a city ______ has lots and lots of people. It's not a good idea to drink water unless chemicals have been taken out

    (A) that

    (B) in which

    (C) in that

    (D) where

    ==========================================================

    Hi, see you again.

    We live in a city which has lots and lots of people.

    1.We live in a city.

    2.The city has lots and lots of people.

    這句其實有兩個改法...

    A:We live in a city which has lots and lots of people.

    B:The city which we live in has lots and lots of people.

    =The city in which we live in has lots and lots of people.

    =The city where we live has lots and lots of people.

    為何會有兩個寫法呢? 重點在於要強調的東西...

    A句強調我們住在這個城市

    B句強調城市中有許多許多人

    B句與你之前問過的台北101那題一樣...

    此題為A句...

    因為先行詞the city在第二句為主詞用法(S+V)...所以你答案的解答非常正確且明白...在讓你看一次>>>空格前有名詞a city, 而空格後又有動詞has, 可知空格應置入關係代名詞which, 用以代替其前的名詞並作其所引導的形容詞子句之主詞, 而此關係代名詞which可用that取代...

    當然...此句也是可以改為有where的...只要句子改為

    1.We live in a city.

    2.There are lots and lots of people in the city.

    =>We live in a city in which there are lots and lots of people.

    =We live in a city where there are lots and lots of people.(省略in which..city表地方..所以用where)

    ps.句中ㄉlots and lots of...好怪= = 你沒打錯嗎??

    以上

    F.Y.I.

    2006-05-16 02:55:45 補充:

    當關代為主格用法時...絕對不會有where代替which之情形...因為where絕對是當關係子句中動詞或介系詞之"受詞"除非句子改為there....請參考我的例句

    2006-05-16 03:14:09 補充:

    我提到的台北101那一題請見以下連結參考一下我的回答http://tw.knowledge.yahoo.com/question/?qid=120605...

    2006-05-16 23:30:05 補充:

    lots and lots of 會是等於 more and more嗎!?如果是的話我就又學到一樣了^^

    2006-05-19 03:41:24 補充:

    答案是A.THATwhich打習慣了...在例句中都打成which= =

    參考資料: Myself
  • 1 0 年前

    where= in which

    ex: The house is beautiful. I live in the house.

    =>The house which I live in is beautiful.

    = The house that I live in is beautiful.

    = The house in which I live is beautiful.

    原題目中,並沒有in,故不可用where

  • 我覺得是因為句子已經表明''a city'',就不用限定了~!

    如果你要選(d)的話~!where前面要加,變成

    =>We live in a city {,where} has lots and lots of people. It's not a good idea to drink water unless chemicals have been taken out.

    變成非限定用法~!

    參考一下吧~!

    參考資料: 自己
還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。