2.Not waste time. Teacher can give students many knowledge in three to five minutes.
3.Decision-making power was not denude. A college student has power to arrange his listen and life. He should has ability. For example, 臺大醫學系 take “use photograph to roll call” way to ask students have to in class. Reporter interview the students for this thing. Most of students think the way is 干預 their decision-making power in class.
(2)文大上課強制座位 上萬學生抓狂 。(來源：2006/03/09 聯合報)
4.Ditch the class is a fashion. A good student in 暨大 express “Ditch the class is a fashion.” If you are not ditch the class, you are not a college student.
5.To reduce accidents. Many students had an accident for a roll call.
6.Roll call just a form. Someone ditch the class after roll call. The roll call have a meaning ?
Disadvantage：1.Rising business”agent”. A man acting the other in
class will disappear.
2.People is passive. If don’t spur, they will not to learn.
As to above reason, I think a college student shouldn’t roll call in class.
「一個蘿蔔一個坑」It’s not human at all.
- Stephen EdwardsLv 51 0 年前最佳解答
2. So as not to waste time: It takes 3-5 minutes to take an attendance register; time which could be spent teaching.3. The right make one’s own decisions is not infringed. University students have the right to, and should be competent enough to, arrange their own studies and their own lives. For example, National Taiwan University’s medical school uses a photographic register to make sure students attend class. Reporters have interviewed NTU medical school students regarding this matter and most of those felt that this intervenes in their right to make their own decisions. Another example is that of the Chinese Culture University in which students have set seats, something which is opposed by almost all students.4. Skipping class is quite popular nowadays. One outstanding student in National Chi Nan University indicated that skipping class is almost fashionable. Those that have not skipped class are not really considered university students.5. In order to decrease accidents: Many students have accidents while rushing to school to make it in tome for the attendance register.6. Taking the register is just a formality: If someone skips class after the register has been taken then what meaning does the register have?Disadvantages1. The up and coming business of ‘stand ins’, where someone is paid to attend class in place of a student, will disappear if attendance registers are taken.2. People are passive. If they are not pushed then they will not learn.For the above reasons I don’t think that it should be necessary for university students to take a class attendance register.We say that 'every radish has a hole' but people cannot be treated like that.參考資料： Me (英國人)