阿黃 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 1 0 年前

請問文法大大高手關於recommend問題

(一)

題目是"Choose the correct sentence."

A.Four of five doctors recommended that I use Tylenol.

B.Four of five doctors recommended me to use Tylenol

C.Four of five doctors recommended me using Tylenol.

D.Four of five doctors recommended I using Tylenol.

答案是"A"

1.為什麼"B"不行呢,recommend不是可先接受詞再接不定詞嗎?

2."C"的答案若去掉me,是不是就變成正確句子?

(二)第二問題是…

Peter and Tom discussed ___at the meeting

A.to bill clients

B.billing clients

答案是"B",請問為什不能用to bill呢?

4 個解答

評分
  • 1 0 年前
    最佳解答

    1. 當recommend是用來當advise的話,尤其是專業知識的時候,有下面幾種用法(注意recommend後面應該要加建議的東西,而不是建議的對象):

    recommend (that)

    -- I recommend that you get some professional advice.

    -- Doctors strongly recommend that fathers should be present at their baby's birth.

    recommend doing something

    -- I would never recommend using a sunbed on a regular basis.

    -- Sleeping tablets are not recommended in this case.

    -- It is dangerous to exceed the recommended dose.

    這裡有更詳細的解釋: http://www.ldoceonline.com/dictionary/recommend

    2. 這裡billing clients...用billing是拿來當動名詞用當作discuss的受詞.

    參考資料: myself + longman dictionary
    • 登入以對解答發表意見
  • Kuang
    Lv 4
    1 0 年前

    這類動詞稱作意志動詞

    • 登入以對解答發表意見
  • 1 0 年前

    這個最佳解答說的雖然都是對的卻也都是發問者已知的, 沒有搔到發問者的癢處.

    版主, 是的, A與B都是正解, C如刪掉me也是對的.

    B對的原因是有了間接受詞就可接to V.

    如果是單選題, 就是命題者功夫不夠.

    2009-03-12 15:46:50 補充:

    第2題

    billing clients是一個議題, 所以discussed billing clients是正解.

    discussed to bill clients意思變成"為了要跟客戶收費而討論, 中文是OK的, 但英文discuss是及物動詞, 必需有受詞

    e.g. discussed a cause/category to bill clients with

    e.g. discussed how/why/when/whether to bill clients (受詞為片語)

    • 登入以對解答發表意見
  • 匿名使用者
    1 0 年前

    醫生常說: I recommend you to take vitamin pills. 也常說: I recommend taking vitamin pills. 關於recommend問題

    答案是"A"

    C.Four of five doctors recommended me using Tylenol. "C"若去掉me,變成my就成正確句子?動名詞using也可其意義上的主詞 my.

    Four of five doctors recommended my using Tylenol.

    Peter and Tom discussed ___at the meeting

    答案是"B"

    有些動詞及片語後只可接 動名詞為受詞不可接不定詞 .

    TKS,這是好題.

    • 登入以對解答發表意見
還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。