小b 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 9 年前

英文文法不會?

Mr. Wang has taught thousands of students,some of them_____internationally known scholars.

1have become

2having become

3may have become

答案是1

我想知道的是 have become 為什麼不對,還有如果是用 may having become

正確嗎?

已更新項目:

烏茲拉拉x狗

更正~~答案是2才對,我打錯了

不過大大如果文法夠好,就算我答案給錯應該也能看出問題,

你的解釋只有一半正確,我了解了may having become 因為may是

助動詞,所以不行。

不過我還是不了解 為什麼用現在完成式的 have becom不行呢?

2 個已更新項目:

to Louis 大

這題你的解釋也不正確呢,看來這題難度真的蠻高的,文法書上的說明是

Mr. Wang has taught thousands of students,some of them have become internationally known scholars.

他說這個句子是有問題的,好像是兩句子沒有連接詞的樣子,不過我還是不太懂,

為什麼換成having become 就正確,不知道有沒有人知道。

4 個解答

評分
  • 呆子
    Lv 7
    9 年前
    最佳解答

    Mr. Wang has taught thousands of students,some of them_____internationally known scholars.

    =Mr. Wang has taught thousands of students ; some of them have become internationally known scholars.

    =Mr. Wang has taught thousands of students ;and some of them have become internationally known scholars.

    本句還原為:

    Mr. Wang has taught thousands of students,some of them who have become internationally known scholars.

    Mr. Wang has taught thousands of students,(some of them having become internationally known scholars.本句為插入句,說明students)*****

  • 9 年前

    這題不是難度高,而是選 1 錯,選 3 錯,選 2 是爛英語!

    分詞構句本身是有意思的,不是這種用法。它不是隨便去掉連接詞,把子句的動詞改成分詞就可以放心睡覺了。

    這句話在你們現在的英文程度,最好的說法是「最簡單」的 ..., and some of them have become ...

  • 9 年前

    001是正確的,但第4句須加and

    分詞構句,兩句的主詞不同時,分詞構句的主詞必須保留

    分詞構句 參考網站

    http://203.64.184.214/reading/analysis/grammar/sho...

    http://english.nhsh.tp.edu.tw/p21-12.htm

    2010-10-09 17:39:50 補充:

    Sorry! 修正第4句…thousands of students, some of whom have become …

  • 痾....

    大大你問題是不是問錯了

    你說1是答案

    妳卻又說have become是錯的

    我先幫你解答為什麼having become是錯的

    因為那些學生是已經變成所以要用have而不是having

    至於may having become能不能用

    答案是否

    因為may 本身是助動詞

    所以後面的動詞要變成原形

    所以正確的話可能是may have become 解釋為可能已經變成....

還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。