serina 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 9 年前

有關wh開頭疑問句問題

有關英文問題想請教各位大大,

1. 如果一問句wh開頭 question 有Verb或action,

則回答時,是否一定要有do /does /did ?

example. Where did you do last weekend ?

以這句話來說,可否換為=> Where were you do last weekend

?

如果不行,是不是因為這個疑問句有do這個action的關係 ?

2. What day is today ? 是否可改為=> How about weater is today ?

3. 我常在疑問句上面有疑惑,因為常無法從一個答句中知道其上一個疑問句問的重點是什麼?

for example. I am working at home today.

此句話要問的是 : Where are you work today ? 還是 : What are you doing today ?

感謝各位大大的幫忙.

已更新項目:

Dear 老鄧,很感謝你的回覆,

所以,

1 . 回覆內容中 : A : go =>對應=> B : went, 那嚜為什麼A句中要有did呢? 我知道它是助動詞,有其他助動詞可以代替嗎? (如下)

A: Where did you go last night ?

B: I went to a movie last night.

2 個已更新項目:

Dear 老鄧,

可否再請教一個問題,

have been to & have gone to 有何不同 ?

尤其是have gone to...

謝謝喔

2 個解答

評分
  • 老登
    Lv 7
    9 年前
    最佳解答

    . 如果一問句wh開頭 question 有Verb或action,

    則回答時,是否一定要有do /does /did ?

    example. Where did you do last weekend ?

    以這句話來說,可否換為=> Where were you do last weekend

    wh疑問詞和回答是否要用 do/does/did 是一點關係都沒有的.

    疑問句中如果是用 be動詞問,那麼回答就要用 be動詞回答,如:

    A: What is your brother?

    B: He is a doctor.

    疑問句如果是用助動詞 do/does/did 問時,回答時,問什麼答什麼,如:

    A: Where did you go last night ?

    B: I went to a movie last night.

    A: What did you do last night?

    B: I played tennis last night.

    版主的例句是不正確的.

    2. What day is today ? 是否可改為=> How about weater is today ?

    what day is today? 是問 " 今天是幾月幾日", 非"天氣"!

    It is October 2, 2011.

    3. 我常在疑問句上面有疑惑,因為常無法從一個答句中知道其上一個疑問句問的重點是什麼?

    for example. I am working at home today.

    此句話要問的是 : Where are you work today ? 還是 : What are you doing today ?

    疑問句和回答句時態是一致的.

    回答句一定是回答前面的問句.

    版主的 What are you doing today? 是不正確的,進行式是瞬間的動作,不可以用 today 一整天.

    A: Where are you going now?

    B: I am going to school.

    A: What did you have for lunch?

    B: I had a hamgurger for lunch.

    A: Which girl do you like, Jenny or May?

    B: I like Jenny better.

    2011-10-02 20:57:42 補充:

    是要看疑問詞是問什麼? 如下:

    what ............什麼, (人)...職業,

    where...........地方

    when............何時

    who ..............人,或關係

    how...............如何

    2011-10-02 20:57:58 補充:

    What did you have for lunch? ....have 做"吃"解釋,

    你吃什麼?

    What are you? 你是何職業?

    Where did you go? 你去哪裡?

    When did you go? 你何時去的?

    Who did you go with? 你和誰去的?

    How did you go? 你如何去的?

    2011-10-02 20:58:07 補充:

    至於疑問句中的助動詞,不管有沒有疑問詞wh-, 只要是用的是普通動詞,就要用助動詞來變問句,助動詞 do/does/did 本身並沒有任何中文意思,所以變問句之後,意思不會變.

    但是如果你改用其他助動詞,(如 can) , 意思就會變掉.

    What did you do ?.........你做了什麼? I did my homework.

    注意: 答句的did是動詞喔.

    What can you do? .....你會做什麼? ...(意思不同)

    這樣了解了嗎?

    2011-10-02 21:02:19 補充:

    有問題可再提問! 不用客氣 .

    2011-10-05 22:03:34 補充:

    此兩個都是現在完成式

    have been to 是曾經去過,現在人不在那裡

    I have been to States for many times. 我曾去過美國很多次

    have gone to 是已經去了XX地方,現在人還在那裡

    He has gone to Japan. 他已經去日本了

  • 9 年前

    Dear 老鄧,很感謝你的回覆,

    所以,

    2. " 疑問句如果是用助動詞 do/does/did 問時,回答時,問什麼答什麼,"

    如下例句是指疑問句Verb 問什麼的時候, 回答句就要看疑問句Verb去回答嗎?

    A: Where did you go last night ?

    B: I went to a movie last night.

    2011-10-02 19:55:17 補充:

    3. 從您提供的例句中,如果沒有先看疑問句,而直接從回覆句中判斷疑問句時,如下例句,此例句問的是"你中午吃什麼",還是"你何時吃hamburger" ?,因為我常無法從回復句中判斷主要問的是什麼,有什麼方法可以判斷嗎?

    B: I had a hamburger for lunch.

還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。