孟聰 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 8 年前

as well as 改成疑問句 動詞該跟哪個主詞?

Not only you but also he "has" to go to the makeup class.

因為動詞是跟著"近"的主詞所以用has

所以改成疑問句:"Do" not only you but also he have to go to the makeup class?

Do跟著靠近的you跑

那麼文法書上說as well as 是跟著"遠"的主詞跑

那麼我到底該說Do you as well as he have to...

還是Does you as well as he.....

因為我好像聽過別人說(as well as B)整個是個副詞

所以一定要跟著as well as前面的主詞

是這樣嗎?

已更新項目:

Louis:

那麼

:"Do" not only you but also he have to go to the makeup class?

我上面講的這句not only but also句行的用法對嗎?

1 個解答

評分
  • Louis
    Lv 7
    8 年前
    最佳解答

    Do you as well as he have to ...才對

    對主要動詞have來說,you才是較遠的主詞,do是因為倒裝才移到句前的。

    as well as he是附加的資訊,所以在句中不可喧賓奪主,占有主詞的地位。

    遠東新世紀辭典的說明引用如下:

    A as well as的結構中,在意義上重點置於A,因此以A為主詞的述部動詞的[單複數]應與A符合:John, as well as his friends, was injured in the accident.

    (以上在該辭典p.1572 as well as的語法說明)

    上面這句用逗號將as well as his friends與主句隔開,讓句意的關係更清楚。

    在這下面這種用法才是A與B同樣重要:In theory as well as in practice, the idea was unsound。

    2011-11-17 11:58:32 補充:

    :"Do" not only you but also he have to go to the makeup class?

    上面的這句問話不符英語語法,錯誤。

    肯定句可以是:Not only you but also he have to go the makeup class.

    問句時可能會說:Do you and he both have to go to the makeup class?

    2011-11-29 08:36:46 補充:

    Not only you but also he have to go to the makeup class.

    漏打了一個字to

還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。