請問一題和as soon as有關的英文問題要如何作答

各位大大

請問一題英文

______ my homework, I went home.

(A)Having finished

(B)Finished

(C)As soon as been finished

(D)Being finishing我個人覺得選項(D)應該是錯的

因為這題的句子不可能會有兩個現在分詞連用的狀況吧

不過我想請大大教我其他三個選項(A)(B)(C)要如何分析對錯

謝謝

已更新項目:

阿昌大大

請問選項(C)是對的還是錯的

2 個已更新項目:

prisoner26535大大

為何你判斷選項(C)是錯的

麻煩解說一下可以嗎

3 個已更新項目:

prisoner26535大大

請問你判斷選項(C)錯誤的理由是甚麼

4 個解答

評分
  • 9 年前
    最佳解答

    To explain this question with grammar, it will take quite an effort. However, in the end, poster might not be able to utilize it well after so much of grammar rules are used to explain. Therefore, let me use logic!

    In this question, the only reasonable answer is (A). I will get into the detail later. Let me explain why (B), (C), and (D) are not good to choose:

    To choose (B), you need to write the sentence as:

    After I finished my homework, I went home.

    After I had finished my homework, I went home.

    To choose (C), you need to write the sentence as:

    As soon as I have finished my homework, I went home.

    Ad soon as my homework was finished, I went home.

    To Choose (D), you need to write the sentence as:

    When my homework was being finished, I went home (in the sentence,

    the homework was NOT finished)

    After finishing my homework, I went home.

    Now, back to choice (A), "having finished the homework" is called the Ving phrase. it is an adverb to describe "went". You can also use "finishing my homework". However, since "I went home" is in past tense. Therefore, whatever was done before 'I went home" shall be in present perfective or past perfective or past tense. However, when you use "past perfection" or "past" tense without a subject (like in choice (B)), but as a past participle phrase, it can imply as a passive tense, so in this case, since "homework" was done by me, so it is better to use Ving phrase to indicate an active tense.

    2012-01-23 12:52:40 補充:

    master 26535, I am very sure, everybody on your list will tell you so!

    2012-01-23 13:59:35 補充:

    At the beginning, NO!. Now, probably there is!

    參考資料: self
  • Louis
    Lv 7
    9 年前

    ______ my homework, I went home.

    (A)Having finished這是完成式的分詞,其時間點在主要動詞went之前發生,符合全句的時序和邏輯,所以是正確的。

    (B)Finished這是簡單式的分詞,表示其時間點與主要動詞went同時發生,不符時序,且過去分詞表示被動,也不符語意,因為finished在邏輯上的受詞不是本句的主詞[我]。

    (C)As soon as been finished在as soon as後面應該接一個完整的句子,表示兩件事在時間上同時發生。但此處無主詞,且動詞部分是隨意組合而成的,同時用了兩個過去分詞在一起,並不符語法(像是完成式被動態,但不完整)。

    (D)Being finishing分詞通常只有簡單式和完成式,不會用進行式,且being在前的寫法,是表示因為的意思,如:Being a student, I know the importance of Enblish.

  • 9 年前

    AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

    2012-01-23 11:34:45 補充:

    (X) As soon as been finished my homework, I went home.

    (O) As soon as my homework was finished, I went home.

    2012-01-23 12:31:19 補充:

    (C) is wrong because a little bird told me so. Hmm, was it the Lion? Might have been the little bunny. Or, the priest? or the Melon?

    2012-01-23 13:24:33 補充:

    Melon dude, help! I have no idea why it is wrong.

    Do all girls need to know human taxonomy before making babies?

  • 阿昌
    Lv 7
    9 年前

    ____我的功課,我就回家了。

    (A)在完成

    (B)成品

    (C)為盡快完成

    (D)被整理

還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。