rik 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 7 年前

英文give 問句

She gave him the book.

1. Did she give him the book?

2. what did she give him?

3 what she gave him?

4 what is that she gave him?

5 who did she give the book?

6 whom did she give the book?

7 who she gave the book?

8 whom she gave the book?

9 who is the one she gave the book ?

she gave the book to him.

10. Did she give the book to him?

11. what did she give to him?

12. what she gave to him?

13.what is that she gave to him?

14.who did she give the book to?

15 whom did she give the book to?

16. who she gave the book to?

17 whom she gave the book to?

18. who is the one she gave the book to?

以上 18 個問句 文法上有錯嗎?

請高手 回答

3 個解答

評分
  • 羅莉
    Lv 7
    7 年前
    最佳解答

    She gave him the book.

    1. Did she give him the book? (O)

    2. what did she give him? (O)

    3 what she gave him?

    這是名詞子句, 整個子句可作為間接問句的受詞.

    4 what is that she gave him?

    這是名詞子句, 整個子句可作為間接問句的受詞.

    5 who did she give the book to? 美式

    間接受詞不緊貼授與動詞時, 要有介系詞.

    6 whom did she give the book to? 英式

    間接受詞不緊貼授與動詞時, 要有介系詞.

    7 who she gave the book to? 美式

    缺助動詞, 這是名詞子句, 整個子句可作為間接問句的受詞.

    間接受詞不緊貼授與動詞時, 要有介系詞.

    8 whom she gave the book to? 英式

    缺助動詞, 這是名詞子句, 整個子句可作為間接問句的受詞.

    間接受詞不緊貼授與動詞時, 要有介系詞.

    9 who was the one she gave the book to? 美式

    時態應一致.

    間接受詞不緊貼授與動詞時, 要有介系詞.

    she gave the book to him.

    10. Did she give the book to him? (O)

    11. what did she give to him? (O)

    12. what she gave to him?

    這是名詞子句, 整個子句可作為間接問句的受詞.

    13.what was that she gave to him?

    時態應一致.

    14.who did she give the book to? (O) 美式

    15 whom did she give the book to? (O) 英式

    16. who she gave the book to? 美式

    這是名詞子句, 整個子句可作為間接問句的受詞.

    17 whom she gave the book to? 英式

    這是名詞子句, 整個子句可作為間接問句的受詞.

    18. who was the one she gave the book to? 美式

    時態應一致.

    建議:

    養成良好習慣, 句子起首要大寫。

    2013-02-19 09:32:43 補充:

    更正:

    4 what WAS that she gave him?

    時態應一致.

    2013-02-19 21:32:22 補充:

    傳統文法凡是關代作為受詞時就要用whom, 只有到了現代美語才改用who(僅保留緊接介系詞後的關代用whom), 故美式英語是who與whom保持並行; 而在英式英語則大多仍用正統受格whom, 但少部份也已接受用who.

    參考資料: 羅莉 + 英文文法
  • 匿名使用者
    7 年前

    在美國念書的時候老師也說現在多用who代替whom,雖然兩個都可以

    但whom因為太過老派的正式反而會讓人覺得很怪,

    除非在非常正式的場合或是你是念英語文學系的才會特別用whom

  • 7 年前

    不一定用 whom 就代表英式,而是比較正式的用法。

    2013-02-20 07:19:16 補充:

    不過我在英國這邊聽到的也多為 who,

    當我使用 whom 時,他們說這是 more formal 的用法。

    舉例來說:

    Who did she give the book to?(這樣的用法在英國也很常見)

    Whom did she give the book to?(較前句正式)

    To whom did she give the book?(傳統英文文法,現很少用,除非在高級社交場合,想展現你的英文程度)

還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。