promotion image of download ymail app
Promoted
SongLin 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 7 年前

(英文)關係代名詞文法問題

People who want to try ceramics just have to visit a small town in north Taiwan

幫我講解一下這個文法的來龍去脈

如果People who to try ceramics that just have to visit a small town in north Taiwan

這樣可以嗎?

幫我解釋一下關係代名詞的適當用法

已更新項目:

第二句多了一個WHO

應該是這樣People want to try ceramics that just have to visit a small town in north Taiwan

2 個解答

評分
  • Louis
    Lv 7
    7 年前
    最佳解答

    People who want to try ceramics just have to visit a small town in north Taiwan.

    who want to try ceramics是限定性質的修飾語(所以未用逗號與先行詞隔開),將普通名詞people的範圍加以縮小,否則泛所有的人。

    People want to try ceramics that just have to visit a small town in north Taiwan.

    這樣會有語病,因為後面的子句that just have to visit a small town in north Taiwan會變成名詞ceramics的限定性修飾語,關係代名詞that=先行詞ceramics。語意不通,瓷器不會去visit a small town,應該是人,才能做這種事。

    寫成 People want to try ceramics just have to visit a small town in north Taiwan.也不通。因為動詞have to visit和前面的want to try無語法關係,不能並存。

    2013-07-19 10:50:54 補充:

    Many people visit a small town in north Taiwan and try ceramics there.

    用and連結兩個述部,語法才正確。

    2013-07-28 23:47:44 補充:

    Many people visit a small town in north Taiwan and try to make ceramics there.

    這樣後半段句意才完整。

    • Commenter avatar登入以對解答發表意見
  • 幻星
    Lv 5
    7 年前

    People who want to try ceramics just have to visit a small town in north Taiwan

    (People who want to try ceramics)主詞

    have to visit....>>>動詞

    後面不可加that

    要不然這整句會變成沒有動詞

    who want to try ceramics 是用來修飾People

    如果加that 會變成修飾ceramics整句就沒有動詞了

    但是前面who可以省略

    >>People want to try ceramics just have to visit a small town in North Taiwan.

    • Commenter avatar登入以對解答發表意見
還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。