楙盛 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 6 年前

did was 的回答(急

Who sang the song? 答案是A-Mei ''did'' 可是為什麼不能用was 請各位大大幫我一下

4 個解答

評分
  • 最佳解答

    不是不能用而是什麼時候使用

    A: Who sang the song?

    B: A-Mei did.

    A: Who sang the song?

    B: It was A-Mei.

    A: Who sang the song?

    B: A-Mei was the one ( sang the song ).

    2014-10-11 04:47:30 補充:

    例句一

    文法正確但回答很無聊

    例句二跟三

    普通對話常有的反應

    2014-10-11 16:20:43 補充:

    "初學者有些規則先記住" ... this is very true...however, there's nothing wrong to get to know how people speak in normal ways. Have fun studying English. English does not equal to grammar. Just relax and learn with fun for yourself.

    2014-10-11 16:26:47 補充:

    It is beneficial to remember all the grammar rules. However, so many students are bound by it and then get all startled when they have to open their mouth and speak.....coz in their brain, they are looking for the right grammar rule first instead of sorting out what they really wanna express

    參考資料: , Live in the USA too long, Live in the USA too long
  • 6 年前

    你好 :)

    sang = sing的過去式 =唱

    "唱"是一個動作 所以是動詞

    所以要用助動詞"do"的過去式 "did"來回答

    was是 be動詞

    be動詞不能跟動詞放在一起

    所以回答不可能是用"was"

    真的要放在一起的話 就要把動詞+ing 變成動名詞 (就是現在進行式)

    希望對你有幫助 ><

    參考資料: 自己:)
  • rhody
    Lv 7
    6 年前

    初學者有些規則先記住,其他的以後再說,看這裡(只看第一段的規則就好)

  • Louis
    Lv 7
    6 年前

    因為sang是一個action verb,「唱」歌是動作,所以回答時,要用表示動作的助動詞did。

    was是stative verb,表示的是一個「狀態」,不是動作,所以不能用來回應action verbs的sang。除非原問句用的是be動詞當主要動詞或助動詞(被動態),回答才有可能出現am/is/are/was/were等。

還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。