ddd 發問時間: 政治與政府法律與道德 · 5 年前

美國哪些州刑法不採取想像競合?

為甚麼有犯罪者可以被判幾個無期徒行刑(consecutive life sentence)

都是一罪一罰嗎?

無期徒行刑沒假釋(Life without parole )是甚麼?代表這個人一背子都要在監獄度過嗎?

判100年是否關100年?

台灣傾向廢除想像競合未來是否會像美國一樣?殺3人可能被判3個無期??

2 個解答

評分
  • Gary
    Lv 7
    5 年前
    最佳解答

    1. Consecutive life sentence is merely a symbolic measure for the victims' family. It has no true legal effect.

    Instead, the consecutive life sentence provides a relief to the victims' family that the convicted is responsible for each of his/her victims.

    2. Life without parole, in plain language, means life imprisonment without chance to parole. Unless a pardon is granted (which is unlikely, even if granted, it will convert to life with parole only), the person stays in the prison forever.

    However - it has more meaning that it looks. Life without parole is only offered as an option for first-degree murder as an alternative of death penalty when there is either not enough evidence to support death penalty or the state has banned death penalty.

    All other life imprisonments are life with parole.

    3. No. 100-year of imprisonment does not mean the person has to serve 100 years.

    When certain conditions are met (good behavior, restitution, etc.), each state allows prisoners to petition for early release or parole.

    And surprisingly - 100-year sentence is not a life sentence in theory, but in practice.

    4. No - it actually simplifies the process and will result more conviction. By using this doctrine, a court need to analyze the suspects' behavior (does A lead to B?). However, without this doctrine, the court simply need to focus on the evidence support each of the charges.

    For example, you broke into a car and stole some valuable. Under this doctrine, you will be punished for breaking, not stealing (as stealing carries less severity). However, with this doctrine, you will be punished by both.

    台灣傾向廢除想像競合未來是否會像美國一樣?殺3人可能被判3個無期??

    • 登入以對解答發表意見
  • 5 年前

    為甚麼有犯罪者可以被判幾個無期徒行刑(consecutive life sentence)

    都是一罪一罰嗎?

    因為他犯很多案件

    例如殺5個人,5個人就分開審理

    所以就判很多罪名

    無期徒行刑沒假釋(Life without parole )是甚麼?代表這個人一背子都要在監獄度過嗎?

    代表永遠不給予假釋

    就是關一輩子

    判100年是否關100年?

    不一定

    例如依美國法律,州長或總統就職都會減刑

    所以判100年也許關10年就出獄了

    台灣傾向廢除想像競合未來是否會像美國一樣?殺3人可能被判3個無期??

    應該是吧

    看立法院

    • 登入以對解答發表意見
還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。