Choco 發問時間: 社會與文化語言 · 2 年前

What caused the tree to fall? What疑問代名詞 caused動詞 the tree名詞 to fall不定詞 ; 該句是疑問句為何沒有助動詞而將動詞搬到前面?

5 個解答

評分
  • 2 年前
    最佳解答

    cause:-

    Do not say "cause that someone does something";

    Say "Cause someone to do something"

    cause to make something happen, especially something bad:-

    eg--:"-Bad weather" has caused the tree to fall.----(aux.verb=has;----v=caused----v--n--inf to---)

    -----What has caused the tree to fall ?--------HAS CAUSED

    -----"Bad weather"

    eg:-"The worm "caused the tree to fall-------(v=caused----n-- inf. to----)

    ------What caused the TW tree to fall ?----------------CAUSED

    -----"The Taiwan Worms called Choco."

    auxiliary---adj

    auxiliary---an auxiliary motor,piece of equipmemt etc is kept ready to be used if the main one stops working properly;am auxiliary power supply;

    auxiliary verb-n--

    a verb that is used with another verb to show its tense, person, mood etc. In English the auxiliary verbs are "be","do", "have" "caused"(as in I am eating,I do go, I didn't go, I have gone, the trees have caused; the tree caused, --the root cause caused the tree to fall ?!----Choco powdering is the main cause of root disease (that) caused the tree to fall ?!)

  • Louis
    Lv 7
    2 年前

    你可以用答句的結構來檢查問句的主詞是那一個字:

    What is your name?

    My name is Paul.

    所以問句裡的疑問代名詞what是「主詞補語」,name才是「主詞」。

    這時問句需要「倒裝」,把「動詞」或「助動詞」移到主詞的前面。動詞is需移到主詞之前。

    What do you want?

    I want something to eat.

    what是問句的受詞,you是主詞,故增加一個助動詞do在主詞前,形成問句的倒裝結構。

    Who gave you that book?

    John did.

    問句的主詞是疑問代名詞who是「主詞」,you是間接受詞,book是直接受詞。

    這時的問句「不可倒裝」。

    What caused the tree to fall?

    這句裡的主詞是what,tree是受詞,to fall是受詞補語。

    所以這問句「不可倒裝」。

    結論:主詞是「疑問代名詞」時,疑問句的句構不會倒裝(移動助動詞或動詞到主詞之前)。

    此外,將句尾音調上提的問句(用來確認所聽到的資訊是否正確)也不需倒裝。如:

    B: How old are you?

    A:I am eighty years old.

    B: (You are) eighty years old? (句尾語調提高,可省略前面括號內的文字)

    A: Yes, I AM. (am會加強語氣)

    What caused the tree to fall?這種用疑問字開頭的句子,其語調在句尾是下降的。

  • 2 年前

    英語的文法 只是一般原則的歸納與綜合.常用的日常用句例外一堆.請你不要本末倒置.

    就拿你的問題 "英語疑問句"來說: 英語文法把疑問句分作2類 (1)yes-no questions (2)wh-questions

    1. y-n questions

    像是 Do you like me? Are you going? 這類是從 "肯定句型"根據 "助動詞/主詞 句中 位置的交換"所形成的疑問句

    2. wh-questions

    像是 who framed the Rabbits? When will you come?這類的.這種類的疑問句 當疑問的目標會是預期答案的主詞 的時候 就不會有 對調位置的需要

    例子們:

    Q: who cut the tree? (不須對調)

    A: He did.

    Q: what did he have? (對調)

    A: He had some soup.

    3. 你又要把這隻文法背起來了嗎? 請你不要再犯錯,本末倒置了好嗎?

  • 2 年前

    What caused the tree to fall? ←← "what"係疑問代名詞,無助動詞,這句子符合文法。

    What did cause the tree to fall? ←← "what"係疑問代名詞,"did"(助動詞)是強調語氣用,這句子符合文法。

  • 您覺得這個回答如何?您可以登入為回答投票。
  • p
    Lv 7
    2 年前

    疑問句不一定都要有助動詞

還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。